REVISED
DRAFT |
May 10/06 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
UNDERGROUND
COAL MINING SAFETY RESEARCH COLLABORATION - U/G COAL LEGISLATIVE REVIEW -
SUMMARY OF COMPARISON BC:Alta:NS:Fed(CBDC 1990). |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
TOPIC |
B.C. CODE |
ALTA
CODE |
NS U/g Mining Regulations 2003 |
CBDC (Fed) 1990 Regs |
MISSING or NOT |
INITIAL COMMENTS |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
GENERAL |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Scope |
Act 2: |
Reg
1; Code Pt1.1;Pt36.531: |
Act 17-18: |
3: (u/g at CBDC only) |
Generically in all |
BC & Alta inc. surface & u/g
mines in same Cade; NS & Fed have Reg's (not Code) and do not; Fed is for
CBDC only |
|
Obligations - employers |
Act 21/24(1) |
Act 2(1); 32; Code Pt.36.685-6 |
Act 18-19 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC- Apt a mgr and comply with
Act/Reg/Code |
|
Obligations - workers |
Act 24(2) |
Act 2(1); 14; Code Pt36.684 |
Act 17-18: u/g |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC-comply with Act/Reg/Code |
|
Inspectors & Powers |
Act 3-9/15/19/31, Reg'n |
Act 5 |
Act 47-53/73 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC-Min>Ch.Ins.Mines delegates
powers to inspectors > inspections &invesitgations |
|
Advisory Body |
Act 9 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Act 24-26 |
CMSC |
Not in Alta/CBDC? |
BC-allows a main and regional Adv
bodies to assist CI in
approvals/investigations |
|
Permits |
Act 10-11;Code7.2,8.11.1,10.4.1 |
AUEB |
35-49; NSDNR; NSDEL |
CMSC/NSDNR/NSDEL |
Generically in all |
BC-Min>Ch.Ins.Mines issues permits
from-cradle-to-grave, including bonding, others may cover this elsewhere |
|
Mine reclamation fund
(bonding) |
Act 12 |
AUEB |
NSDNR; NSDEL |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC-requires mine specific reclamation
bonding in Code, others may cover this elsewhere |
|
Variances |
Act 13; Code 1.2 |
Act 34 (1); Reg.10; CodePt.1.1.A; |
Act
83, Regs 3(1),116-118 |
Can Lab Code (CLC)
II-137(1)(2)>CMSC; 5 |
Generically in all |
BC-Ch.Ins>variances, = or >
OHS; Alta-Dir>acceptance, = or > OHS; NS-Dir>deviation;
Fed-CMSC>exemption OHS not diminished |
|
Inspections |
Act15(1)-16,Reg'n,1.6.3/5.3 |
Act 8-11/15; Code
Pt.36.604/690/730 |
Act 66, 82,116-117/121 |
39, 41-47 |
Generically in all |
BC-can inspect at any
time, report in 7 days mgmt resp in 15 days; Alta officer has much power can
sop work & order correction |
|
Abandoned Mines |
Act 17 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not specific (ref.161 closure) |
In BC only |
BC-Ins can make safe, remediate
pollution for abandoned mine(s)>lien, others may cover it elsewhere |
|
Engineering Reports |
Act 18 |
Act 27 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
CMSC |
Not in NS/CBDC? |
BC-Ins can order mine to provide
Eng/prof report into anHS issue or invest'n concern, Alta Minister may engage
on OHS matters; |
|
Managers/Supervisors |
Act 21-24/26;Code1.7.1/1.8.1/6.1-6.7 |
Act 34; Code
Pt.36.683/685, |
61-64 |
8-9, |
Generically in all |
All
require a Mgr; BC-have aMineMrg/Supervisorsdaily or deign/quaif'd, must comly
with regs/Code; |
|
Manager's Temp'y Absence |
Act 23 |
Pt.36.684-685 |
63 |
Temp'y not mentioned, Perm't>Reg 8 |
Not in CBDC? |
BC-responsible person (Mgr's cert);
Alta-acting Mgr(Mgr's cert, being reviewed); NS-alternte (Mgr's qual'n) |
|
Contractors |
Act 25 |
Act 2(3)-(5)/3/4 |
Act 14-16 |
Not mentioned, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC-Contractor & his ConMgr must
comply with regs and if not treated as Mine Mgr; Alta & NS include them
as responsible |
|
Plans |
Act 27, 6.3/6.8/10.1 |
Pt.36.533/556/681 |
19,25,43-51,53,55-57 |
Pt VI, 158-161 |
Generically in all |
BC-Mgr
post uptodate plans in office; Alta Part 2 Haz. Assess. PEng certifies
changes, NS plans by approp.engr. |
|
OHS Committee |
Act 32 |
Act 6/7/31; Code Pt.13 |
Act 27-33; Reg 23-24 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere, CLC? |
Generically in all |
BC-mines must have OHSCs according to
regs and they must be active |
|
Appeals/Enforcement |
Act 33/35 |
Act 16-17/42-44 |
Act 54-57/67-72 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC-appeal to ChInsp.; insp powers to
enforce |
|
Accident Investigation |
Act 7-8; Reg; 1.7 |
Act 18-19 |
Act 63-65; Reg 28 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere, CLC? |
Generically in all |
BC- CI/insp can investigate
death/injury/env.damage |
|
Absence of Code Req't |
1.1.2 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Can Lab Code II-137(1)(2)>CMSC |
In BC only |
Only specific mention in BC Code |
|
Keep records at the mine site |
Act27/28/30; Code
6.4.2/6.6.1/7.9 |
Pt5.34; Pt.36.690(1) |
Act 34-35;
Reg.8-18/20/29-34 |
4, |
Generically in all |
In all in one form or another |
|
Offence/Penalty |
Act 37 |
Act 41 |
Act 74; Reg.60 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere, CLC? |
Not in CBDC? |
In all in one form or another;
BC-$100k =/- jail + $0.5-5k/day until fixed |
|
Surveyors |
Not specific [10.1.10(4)] |
Pt.36.682, 747(6,7) |
71 |
2, 160 |
Generically in all |
BC-no specific mention, maybe for
plans - only if CI requires |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Hazard
Assessment |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere (Act 18-Engr.Report?) |
Pt.2 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in NS/CBDC? |
Alta only has a
specific requirement in Code for hazard assessment of all work sites |
|
Board of Inquiry |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Act 38 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not found in
regulations |
Not in BC/NS/CBDC? |
Alta only has a
specific requirement in Code for a possible Board of Inquiry if in public
interest |
|
Max. Working Hours |
1.5 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
89 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in Alta/CBDC? |
BC-max 50hrs/wk, max
shift 16hrs, other conditions; NS-normal shift 8hrs/wk, max shift 16hrs,
other conditions; others maybe elsewhere |
|
Bonus Plan |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
90 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere, CMSC? |
Not in BC/Alta/CBDC? |
NS-allows under
certain conditions; CBDC praticed a bonus scheme under union contract |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
DANGEROUS OCCURENCES |
1.7 |
Pt.36.544.1/2 |
27(1), 28, 123, 128;
Act 63 |
162-166, 46 |
Generically in all |
BC report in
<16hrs; Alta as soon as poss; NS<24hrs; CBDc "forthwith" |
|
Rockfalls, subsidences |
1.7.3.1 |
Pt.36.544.1a |
27 (1,f), 27 (2,j/n) |
46 |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta in detail; NS
somehwat generic deals with reporting and correction asap; CBDC genereic:
evcuate, post report |
|
Dam failures |
1.7.3.2 |
Pt.36.544.2 |
27 (1, c) (2, n) |
46 |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta in detail; NS
somehwat generic deals with reporting and correction asap; CBDC genereic:
evcuate, post report |
|
Hoists |
1.7.3.3,4 |
Pt.36.544.1g |
27 (2, h) |
46 |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta in detail; NS
somehwat generic deals with reporting and correction asap; CBDC genereic:
evcuate, post report |
|
Inrushes |
1.7.3.3,4 |
Pt.36.541.2.a/544.1g/749 |
27 (1, c), 109-110 |
54,55 |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta in detail; NS
somehwat generic deals with reporting and correction asap; CBDC genereic:
evcuate, post report |
|
Explosions |
1.7.3.5 |
Pt.36.544.1d |
27 (1, e) (2, c) |
46 |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta in detail; NS
somehwat generic deals with reporting and correction asap; CBDC genereic:
evcuate, post report |
|
Gas inflows |
1.7.3.6 |
Pt.36.544.1e/749 |
27 (1,h//1) |
54,126 |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta in detail; NS
somehwat generic deals with reporting and correction asap; CBDC genereic:
evcuate, post report |
|
Ventilation
Stop |
1.7.3.7 |
Pt.36.544.1b |
27 (1, g) |
46 |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta in detail; NS
somehwat generic deals with reporting and correction asap; CBDC genereic:
evcuate, post report |
|
Out-of-control
vehicle |
1.7.3.8 |
Pt.36.544.1c |
27 (2,l) |
46 |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta in detail; NS
somehwat generic deals with reporting and correction asap; CBDC genereic:
evcuate, post report |
|
Fires |
1.7.3.9 |
Pt.36.544.1d, e |
27 (1, a/b) |
46 |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta in detail; NS
somehwat generic deals with reporting and correction asap; CBDC genereic:
evcuate, post report |
|
Electrical |
1.7.3.10 |
Pt.36.544.1f |
27 (2, f/o/p/q) |
46 |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta in detail; NS
somehwat generic deals with reporting and correction asap; CBDC genereic:
evcuate, post report |
|
Outbursts
(Rock & Gas) |
1.7.3.6/11,6.42.1,8.11.2 |
Pt.36.749? |
27 (1, d) |
46 |
Generically in all |
Not specific in BC |
|
Other |
1.7.3.11 |
Pt.36.544.1g |
27 (1) (2) |
46 |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta in detail; NS
somehwat generic deals with reporting and correction asap; CBDC genereic:
evcuate, post report |
|
Geological
Faults |
10.4.3(e) |
Pt.36.707(3)f |
36.e; 111 |
56 |
Generically in all |
Not specific in BC |
|
Self Rescuers |
1.8.8 (not specific
SCSR) |
Pt.36.692(not
specific SCSR) |
87-88; SCSR-80 |
152 |
Generically in all |
BC specifies NIOSH 42
CFR Pt 84; Alta/NS/CBDC specifify none. |
|
Right to
Refuse Work |
Act 15; 1.1 |
Act 9/35-37 |
Act 43-44; 27 (2, e); |
Not found, maybe elsewhere, CLC? |
Not in CBDC? |
Could not find it in
Alta. |
|
Training |
1.11 |
Pt. 29.397 |
Reg.15; Part 12 |
35(3), 57 |
Generically in all |
Both require trained
& qual'd supervisors. |
|
Supervision ) |
1.12.3 |
Pt.36.683/684 |
65, |
8-9 |
Generically in all |
BC by Board of
Exam'rs; Alta/NS under OHS Reg'ns. |
|
Job
Certification Procedure |
1.13 |
Reg: 24-34 |
Part 12, 424 to 468 |
2 - definitions
"certification" |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta/CBDc reuire a
provincial Board of Examiners to certify comptency; NS does not>employers
Job Training Program |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Alta allows temporary
non-certified substitutes. BC min.age 18 yrs; Alta? |
|
OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Work place
Contaminants |
2.1 |
Reg 2-4 |
NSDEL |
Not found, maybe elsewhere, CLC? |
Not in CBDC? |
BC-Max.Exposures, Shift.Times, |
|
Work Place
Hazards |
2.2 |
Reg 5 |
NSDEL |
Not found, maybe elsewhere, CLC? |
Not in CBDC? |
BC-effective
housekeeping |
|
Hazardous
Materials & Waste |
2.3 |
Reg.4; Pt.20
Radiation, Pt.35 health |
Act 58 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere, CLC? |
Not in CBDC? |
BC-Asbestos,
Others-dusts, wastes, radiation, isocyanites; others less specific |
|
Harmful
Chemical Exposure |
2.4 |
Pt.4;Sched.1 |
NSDEL |
Not found, maybe elsewhere, CLC? |
Not in CBDC? |
BC-emergency wash and
protection |
|
Noise |
2.6 |
Pt.16; Sched.3 |
446 ( r ) [training] |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC-mufflers required |
|
Lasers |
2.7 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Can Lab Code II-137(1)(2)>CMSC? |
Not in Alta/NS/CBDC? |
BC-ANSI
std/protection |
|
Illumination
(see Lighting below) |
2.8(u/g 2.8.3) |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in Alta/NS/CBDC? |
BC-u/g lighting at
specific places, c/v roads, shaft stns, first aid stns |
|
Musculoskeletal
Disorders |
2.9 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in Alta/NS/CBDC? |
BC-modification and
protection |
|
Thermal
Environment |
2.1 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in Alta/NS/CBDC? |
BC-heat/cold stress |
|
Medical
Surveillance |
2.12;8.3.10-11 |
Act 20-24/26 |
Act 42/62 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC-reqts/testing/advice/records/analysis/payment |
|
WHMIS |
2.13 |
Act 29-30; Pt.4;
Pt.29 |
Act 58-60; NS WHMIS
regs 196/88 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC-use/storage/handling/educ/training/labels/MSDS
sheets.Not specific in NS OHS Act or Ug Mining Regs, but in WHMIS Regs. |
|
Threshold
Limit Values |
Table 2-1 |
Schedule 1, Table 2 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in NS/CBDC? |
BC-inc RCD and coal
dust |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
SAFETY |
Pt.3 |
Pt.12 |
Part II (35-58) |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
|
|
Impairment/Violence |
3.1 |
Pt.27 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
142 |
Not in NS? |
BC
- inc.impairment, drugs, liquor, improper conduct; Alta-violence and sources
of ignition; NS not specific on any except ignition; CBDC alcohol, drugs and
sources of ignition |
|
Tallying |
Act 9; 3.2.2 |
Pt.36.691 |
Reg.77-78 |
35(1c) |
Generically in all |
All require a system
of knowing who is u/g at any time [Fed ~37: <15 in a single heading] |
|
Working Alone |
3.2.3 |
Pt. 28/Pt.36.687 |
91, |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC checks <2.5 hr
intervals; Alta no time limit; NS checks <2hr intervals; CBDC-could not
find |
|
Haz./Unsafe
Conditions |
3.3 |
Pt.2/Pt.36.688, Act
35 |
123, |
45, 46, 162 |
Generically in all |
BC manager's plan,
Alta immed.notif'n.& withdrawal, NS immed.withdrawal/correction;
CBDC-immediate report and action |
|
Confined
Spaces |
3.4 |
Pt.5 |
Occ.Saf.Gen.Regs.12/29/137 |
Not found, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Not mentioned
specifically in NS OHS Act or Ug Mining Regs, but maybe as OHS Regs? |
|
Fire
Prevention |
3.5 |
Pt.10; Pt.36.547-558 |
Pt 5, 145-154/164-178 |
146-150 |
Generically in all |
Covered in all to
varying degrees |
|
No Open Flame |
3.5.1/3.5.2 |
Pt.36.621/693 |
156-157 |
141 |
Generically in all |
BC, Alta,
NS-prohibit; CBDC-same as hot work, 24hr notice, test, procedure |
|
No Contraband |
3.1.2/3.5.2 |
Pt.10.162;
Pt.36.693-694 |
156 (1), 157-159 |
142-143 |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta-prohibit,
search not pecified; NS/CBDC- prohibit and search |
|
Welding/Hot
Work |
3.5.1(3)/3,4.4.7 |
Pt.10.169; Pt.18.231;
Pt.36.571/693.4/746 |
160-161 |
141, |
Generically in all |
Alta specifies in
more detail, including lights,flametraps, foil wrap. Fed inc. alcohol &
drugs |
|
Fire-proofing
Roadways |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Pt.36.549 |
162 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in BC/CBDC? |
BC/CBDC - not found;
Alta-specific around c/v drives, desires fire-resistance elsewhere; NS-shafts
and fans, not generic in ine |
|
First Aid |
3.6 |
Pt.11; Sched.2 |
58SchA(25)/374(1)/446/447/455/461-4 |
153, SchV & VI |
Generically in all |
Required in all, NS
mainly injob training |
|
Mine Rescue |
3.7 |
Pt.7.117-118 |
68, 69, 80, 87,
135-143 |
151-154, Sch III, IV |
Generically in all |
BC specific to mine
rescue; Alta is more generic; NS and CBDC in some detail |
|
Emergency
Response |
3.8 |
Pt.7; Pt.36.545-546 |
124-131/165 |
35(1,b) |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Emergency
Training |
3.8 |
Pt.36.545-547 |
126, 440, 455-458 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Specific in
BC/Alta/NS to varying degrees |
|
U/g
Firefighting |
3.9-3.11 |
Pt.36.548-9/554-558 |
145-146? 164, 165,
166 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Specific in
BC/Alta/NS to varying degrees |
|
Evacuation/Escapeways |
3.13; 6.3.1 |
Pt.7.117, Pt.8.119,
Pt.36.702/707 |
125 (2) f) v) |
35.1.a; CMSC |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Emergency
Warning system |
3.13.2-4 |
Pt.36.551/552 |
125(2,g), 131-133 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC/Alta/NS generic:
evacuation warning system req'd; CBDC-no warning system specified |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
BUILDING,
EQUIPMENT, MACHINERY |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
U/g Garages
and fueling |
4.3.1-4 |
Pt.36.704 |
58 SchA (13) |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, except CBDC |
|
U/g Fuel
Stations |
4.3.3 |
Pt.36.697-698/704-5 |
165(1)d171-172 |
100(2) |
Not in CBDC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions |
|
Bulk Fuel
Storage |
4.3.5-9 |
Pt.36.696 |
41, 168, 169-174 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, except CBDC |
|
Welding/Burning |
3.5.1(3)/3,4.4.7 |
Pt.10.169;
Pt.18.231; Pt.36.571/693.4/746 |
160-161 |
141, |
Generically in all |
Found in all,
procedures specified to varying degree of detail |
|
Main surface
fans for u/g ventn |
4.4.13-4.4.14 |
Pt.36.719-721/726 |
204,
218,219 |
114,
116-118 |
Generically in all |
Varying
detail across the jurisdictions |
|
CONVEYORS ) |
4.4.16 |
Pt.36.598-606 |
256, CSA M421-00 |
Not found
specifically, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Only Alta
specifically deals with CO monitors - Pt36.605; CBDC does not specifical
mention them; NS inother reg's |
|
Manriding |
4.4.16.1 |
Pt.36.603 |
) |
Not found
specifically, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC bans manriding;
Alta allows it under specificed conditions; NS/CBDC don't mention it. |
|
Crossing over
on bridges |
4.4.16.2 |
Part 25 373 |
) (278(d) |
Not found
specifically, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Not specified in
Alta/CBDC |
|
Inspection
walkways |
4.4.16.3 |
Pt.36.600/606? |
) |
Not found
specifically, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Alta 36.600 requires
travelling room, inspection walkways not mentioned; CBDC don't mention |
|
Pull cords to
stop |
4.4.16.4 |
Pt.36.599.1 |
)Occ.Safety
Gen.Regs.6/97-100 |
Not found
specifically, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
NS
only has 1 brief section on c/v "testing, maintenance, inspc'n of
c/vs |
|
Audible
pre-start warning |
4.4.16.5 |
Pt.36.552? |
) |
Not found
specifically, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Alta 36.522 requires
emergency warning, c/v audible warning
not mentioned; CBDC doesn't mention |
|
Guarding of
pulleys |
4.4.16.6 |
Pt.22? |
) |
Not found
specifically, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Alta/CBDC don't
mention |
|
Beltslip/Sprinkler/Plugged
chutes |
4.4.16.7 |
Pt36.599.2/604 |
) |
Not found
specifically, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Alta - Sprinkler and plugges chute not
mentioned; CBDC don't mention |
|
Spillage
cleanup |
4.4.16.8 |
Pt.36.548.b/550.a/601 |
) |
Not found
specifically, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
CBDC don't specifically mention |
|
Lock-outs |
4.4.16.9, 4.11 |
Pt.15? |
) |
Not found
specifically, maybe elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Alta/CBDC don't
mention |
|
Guards and
fences |
4.4.16.10 |
Pt.22? |
) |
48, |
Generically in all |
Not specified in Alta |
|
Safe working
procedures |
4.4.16.11 |
Pt.2.7-11 |
) |
52, |
Generically in all |
BC specific to
mine rescue; Alta/CBDC is generic, |
|
Type of
belting |
4.4.16.12 |
Pt.36.598 |
256 (1) |
141 (3) |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta/NS require
CAN/CSA 422-M87; CBDC only fire performance and antistatic belting Fed?? |
|
InspectionExamination |
4.4.16.3 |
Pt36.599.2/604 |
256 (2) |
53, |
Generically in all |
NS
only has 1 brief section on c/v "testing, maintenance, inspc'n of c/vs;
CBDc daily mechanic inspection |
|
Auto Fire
Alarm |
4.4.16.11 |
Pt.36.543-545/551/605 |
) |
129 (longwall) |
Generically in all |
CBDC refer specifically to longwall only |
|
Clearances |
4.4.16.11 |
Pt.36.550/595/600/602/606 |
) |
48, |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
MOBILE
EQUIPMENT |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mobile
Equipment |
4.6/ 4.9 |
Reg.12;Pt.19,
Pt.36.573-596/704-706 |
257-261,274-276,279-289 |
59-60 |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail (CBDC did not use many diesel vehicles so is light on
detail) |
|
|
4.6/ 4.9 |
Pt.36.573-596/704-706 |
254-289 |
59-60 |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Clearances |
6.1.5.2,6.16.1-2,6.17.1 |
Pt.36.595/600/602/606 |
274-277 |
60 |
Generically in all |
NS rail 0.3m
vert/0.6m horz; non-rail 0.6m vert, 1.5/2.0m horiz;Fed 0.3mvert/0.6m horiz |
|
Diesel
Equipment U/g |
4.6.1 |
Pt.36.597/705/732 |
41,171-4,215,225(5),255-261 |
59, 99 -105 |
Generically in all |
Alta, also Pt.19
Mobile Equip. (eg .260 Insp.&Main.; BC specifies min. 0.06 m3/sec of
ventilation air for each kW; not in others. |
|
Trackless
Diesels ) |
4.7.1 |
Pt.36.574/596-597 |
266, |
59-60 |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta/NS
- Ref.CAN/CSA 3.16-99, Mining Diesel Fuel;M424.1-88 Flame-Proof; and
M424.3-M90 Braking Performance; NS also MSHA 30 CFR (2002); CBDC none of
these specified |
|
Flammable
Materials |
4.8.1 |
Pt.10.162 |
162.1 |
144-145 |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Fire
suppression in diesels |
4.9.6 |
Pt.10.166 (1) |
165 (g) |
Not diesel but
108-batt.char'g&115-booster fan |
Not in CBDC? |
In all to varying
degrees of detail (CBDC did not use many diesel vehicles so is light on
detail) |
|
No sparks or
flames from diesels |
3.5.3 |
CSA424.M88/90 |
259, |
99, 103 |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Personnel
Carriers & other cars |
4.9.7,4.9.8 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
266-271 |
59, 81-92 |
Not in Alta? |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Railways |
4.10.1-4 |
Pt.36.706 |
286/386 - locomotives
only |
59-62, 88-89, 100-107 |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Lock-out
Procedures |
4.11 |
Pt.15 |
344(2) - raise
climbers only |
2 - definitions, 49 |
Generically in all |
In BC/AltaCBDC to
varying details |
|
Equipment Auto
Shutdown ) |
4.9.6, Elec = 6.43.4 |
Pt.36.543/738.5/6;
597 - CSA424.M-88/90 |
all=234,
diesel=176(b),electric=235-9 |
115(1) booster fan |
Generically in all |
BC
auto of power at coal face @1.25%; Alta auto of head, manual power off; NS
auto of all including mobile equip, zoned:@ 0.5/1.25% CH4; CBDC: manual@1.25% |
|
Remote
controlled Equipment |
6.18 |
72(3) lifting
devices; 214 lock-out |
76,82,231-2(env),
262-265 |
132 (env-gases) |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Battery
charging |
6.21.1 |
Pt.36.566 |
43, 175 |
108 |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
MECHANICAL |
4.4-4.12/6.16 |
Pt.19 Mobile Powered
Equipment |
55, 200-202, 322-355 |
51-53 |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
fire
resistant fluids |
4.8.3/4['97:4.9.6] |
Pt.36.548(2) |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not found
specifically, maybe elsewhere |
Not in NS/CBDC? |
Found in BC and Alta |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
ELECTRICAL |
5 |
Pt.36.560-572 |
46, 51, 187-199 |
36, 51-52 |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Electrical
Standards ) |
5.1.1/5.2.2-3 |
Pt.36.560 |
189-190, 312, 321 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere, CMSC? |
Not in CBDC? |
Ref. CSA M421-00 Use
of Electricity in Mines AND
Can. Electrical Code; |
|
Electrical
Equip Certific'n |
5.2.3 |
Can Elec Code |
192-193 |
51 |
Generically in all |
BC - requires MSHA or
NRCan's Can. Explosives Lab; Alta not specific |
|
Lighting |
2.8.1/3 |
Part 12 186; CEC |
83-84, 86 |
36 (1-flame
saf'y;2-cap) |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Hazardous
Zoning |
5.1.1/5.2.2/5.2.4/5.3-5.4 |
Pt.10.165-166(5)Pt.36.522/524
CanElecCode |
45, 188, 191-192 |
51 |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Safe
Procedures |
5.3.1 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
52, |
Not in Alta/NS? |
Varying degrees of
detail, maybe elsewhere in NS |
|
Voice
Communication |
7.7.5/10 |
Pt.36.697-699,
704-706 |
82/92 |
151SchIV(12) - mine
rescue only |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail but none specific to 2-way voice mine-wide and especially
not to wireless |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
MINING |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Mine Plans |
Act 27,
6.1.1/6.3.2/6.8/10.1 |
Pt.36.681/708 |
35-60, 90 |
158-160, CMSC? |
Generically in all |
BC/NS specify in
detail & in permit process; Alta needs annual surveyed plan of
prodn.&vent'n; 90days prior submission to CMSC |
|
Shift Reports |
6.4 |
Pt.36.690 |
117, 118, 119 |
33, 45 |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Pre-shift
Inspections |
6.7/6.25 |
Pt.36.690.3 |
75, 117, 118, 119 |
39, 41 |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Haul Roads |
6.9 |
Pt.36.539 |
Occ.Safety
Gen.Regs.15 |
not applicable |
Not in CBDC |
In BC/Alta to varying
degrees of detail implicitly on surface haul roads; not in NS/CBDC as u/g
mines only |
|
Pillars |
6.11,6.25.4/5 |
Pt.36.611.4/747.4 |
52, [47 (1) shaft
pillar?] |
159, |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail; BC - bdy pillars >30m each side; Alta >100m each
side; NS generic (but shaft pillar-60m rad?). |
|
Exploration
Boreholes (u/g) |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Pt.36.748 |
107-109 |
54 |
Not in BC? |
Not in BC, in others
to varying degrees of detail |
|
Mine Openings |
6.12 |
Pt.36.700-702 |
93, 95, 96, 97,208 |
38(2), 61 |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Separation of
int/ret at surface |
6.12.2 (30m) |
Pt.36.700-701(30m) |
93/95/208-30m |
38,109-30m |
Generically in all |
BC/Alta similar
req'ts for portals, mine outlets and escape routes; All need 30m solid or
substantial rock separation. |
|
Min size of
roadways |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
escapeways only, Pt
36:702 |
96, |
38, 61 |
Not in BC? |
Not in BC, in others
to varying degrees of detail |
|
Refuge
Stations |
6.13 |
Pt.36.559 |
146-153 |
Not found |
Not in CBDC? |
Similar req'ts for
contents but BC/NS specify location; Alta more generic; CBDC were
deliberately left out |
|
Bulkheads |
6.14.1 (dams) |
Pt.19.268 (vehicle
stop blocks), 544 (dams) |
27 (dams),
41/42/50/53/58SchA(14) |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Not in CBDC, in
others to varying degrees of detail |
|
Safety
Stns/Manholes |
6.17 |
Pt.36.703 |
277-278 |
60(1.f/3) |
Generically in all |
BC - inspector states
distance apart; Alta is <20m apart; NS:30/50/100 depending on location;
CBDC 100/30 and dimensions |
|
Remote
Control Operation |
6.18 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
76, 82, 262-265 |
132 (env.gases) |
Not in Alta? |
Not specified in Alta
Part 36 Mining or CBDC (except for environmental monitoring) |
|
Battery
Charging |
6.21 |
Pt.36.566 |
43, 156.2.A; 175 |
106-108 |
Generically in all |
Alta requires
Directors approval, also bans battery repairs u/g. |
|
Drilling |
6.24.3 |
Pt.36.537 |
106-107 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Bc requires dust
suppresson in drilling |
|
Old Workings |
6.25/6.40 |
Pt.36.749 |
108-109, 212
barricades |
55,56,159 |
Generically in all |
Not specified
directly in Alta Part 36 Mining; NS probing within 100m. |
|
Inrush/Inflows |
3.3.1/3/6.25.4/6.26 |
Pt.36.749 |
108-112 |
54, 125 (approved
procedure) |
Generically in all |
Alta requires a
scheme for approaching old workings/surface; NS probing within 100m. |
|
Undersea/underwater |
1.7.3.4/10.1.4 f |
Pt 36 749(1) by
inference |
110 |
55 |
Generically in all |
|
|
Interaction |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Pt 36 707(3)g |
111-112 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
|
|
Support of
Roof and Sides |
3.3.1/6.25/10.1.4 f |
Pt.36.707-710/747 |
52, 103-104 |
159 |
Generically in all |
Alta outlines support
sysytem req'ts, operating rules, support withdrawal; Others are generic; CBDC
a geotech plan. |
|
Rock Bolts |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Pt.36.741 |
52 |
159 |
Not in BC? |
Only specified in
Alta |
|
Depillaring |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Pt.36.708/710 |
52 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in BC/CBDC? |
Only specified in
Alta |
|
Backfill |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
113-114 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in BC/Alta/CBDC? |
Only specified in NS |
|
Rock
Passes/Raises/Chutes |
6.26/6.29 |
Pt.36.717 |
105-106 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, except CBDC |
|
Stairways/Ladders |
6.27-28 |
Pt.8.122-137 |
98-102, 340 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, except CBDC |
|
Flammable
Waste (u/g) |
2.3.6/8, 4.3.2(5),
6.3 |
Pt.36.548.1.b/c |
157(3), 168-169 |
114-115 |
Generically in all |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Fire Doors
U/g |
6.32 |
Pt.36.514/548.2.e |
179, 213 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, except CBDC |
|
Subsidence |
10.1.4 f |
Pt.36.544 a |
27,
114, |
55 |
Not in CBDC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, CBDC in context of undersea mining |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
VENTILATION |
6.33 |
Pt.26; Pt.36.711-729 |
53, 203-230 |
109-132 |
Generically in all |
|
|
Vent'n
Plan/surveys |
6.3.2(5);
6.37.1/6.39.2 |
Pt.36.727 |
42.1.a; 204 |
113/119 |
Generically in all |
|
|
Air Quality |
2.1.4, 6.37.2 (4) |
Pt 36 711(1)c |
204 (1, c), 209 (3) |
110,120->19%O2<1.25%CO2 |
Generically in all |
BC>19.5%O2, other
gases, testing |
|
Air Quantity |
4.6.1(3); 6.3.2(5) |
Pt.36.711.1.d |
53(1)d/204(3) 209 (3) |
110/113/119/120/124/150 |
Generically in all |
BC-min0.6m3/sper kW,
others put quantity on vent'n plan |
|
Air Velocity |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Pt.36.712 |
53(2)d/204(1) 209 (3) |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in BC/CBDC? |
BC-not found,
Alta>0.3m/s, NS 20m/min, CBDC not found |
|
Brattice |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Pt.36.724 |
213 |
160 (3) a plans |
Not in BC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, except BC |
|
Cross-cuts/Bleeder |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Pt.36.728/735 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in BC/Alta/CBDC? |
Only specified in
Alta |
|
No compressed
air for vent'n |
6.36.4 |
Pt 36 711(3)b |
209(4),229-230 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, except CBDC |
|
Fixed
Equip/Mine Fans ) |
4.4.13-4.4.14 |
Pt.36.719-721/726 |
204, 218,219 |
114, 116-118 |
Generically in all |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions |
|
Reverse
Flow ) |
4.4.13 |
Pt36.720 |
223 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, except CBDC |
|
Explosion
Doors |
4.4.14.1.b |
Pt 36 721(1) - w.r.t
fan openings |
219(2) |
114(2) |
Generically in all |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions |
|
Offset of fan |
4.4.14.1.a |
Pt 36 721(1) |
219(1,b) |
114 (1) c no distance
spec'd |
Generically in all |
All specify 5m except
CBDC where no distance specified |
|
Booster Fans |
6.36.3(4) |
Pt.36.722, 725-726 |
220, |
115 -118,123-125 safe
op proc |
Generically in all |
BC-only
lt alloys content/ Alta/NS/CBDC specifically deal with booster fans;
BC-Requires inspector's permission; Alta allows only in portal structures; NS
is generic. |
|
U/g Air Heaters ) |
4.4.19/6.35.1 |
Pt.36.548.1.f/695 |
163, |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Generically in all |
Ref. Installation
Codes CSA B139.00 (Oil) B149.1-00 Nat.Gas/Propane), |
|
Return Air |
6.33.1/6.39.1 |
Pt.36.718 |
204, 207 |
110, |
Generically in all |
Clearer in BC than
Alta but implied in Pt.36.718 Splits. |
|
Barometer
Readings |
6.33.2 |
Pt.36.719/727 |
232-233 |
121 |
Generically in all |
|
|
Interruption
to Main Fan |
6.34 |
Pt.36.726.2 |
224-225 |
116 |
Generically in all |
BC requires automatic
withdrawal of personnel; Alta does not; NS withdrawal to a safe place. |
|
Auxialliary
Ventilation |
6.36 |
Pt.36.712.2/723/724 |
204(3/5-6), 226-230 |
114 |
Generically in all |
Alta specifies 0.3
m/sec as min. air velocity; BC/NS don't say; NS no comp.air. |
|
Aux. Fans -
Light Alloys |
6.36.3(4,5) |
Pt.36.538, 725, 726 |
218 |
CMSC |
Generically in all |
BC bans Al, Mg, Ti or
light metal alloy in fans; Alta bans Al blades. |
|
Single
entry/blind headings |
6.36.1 |
Pt.36.701(4), 729 |
93,97,248 |
37, (<15 people) |
Generically in all |
NS <500m |
|
Degassing |
6.36.2/3 |
Pt.36.733-735 |
35?,225(3), 227 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC
specifies <1.25% expl.gas over the fan; Alta/NS don't say; CBDC not
found |
|
Ventilation
Monitoring |
6.37 |
Pt.36.719/727 |
205/6, 232?, 245-6 |
121-122 |
Generically in all |
BC air mmts
<3mths, <1wk in diesel roads; Alta some daily, vent'n<1wk; NS
flam/CO/O2. |
|
Remote
Monitoring & Control |
4.4.16.5 (c/v's) |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
232(1-5), 236(3a) |
132 (env. Gases) |
Not in Alta? |
In all to varying
degrees of detail |
|
Respirable
Particulate RCD |
2.1/table 2-1,
6.37.2(3) |
Pt.36.742.1-744 |
214, 215(1,d),
215(4,f) |
111-113 MRDE Casella |
Generically in all |
BC/NS diesel gases
tested shiftly <1.5mg/m3RCD; Alta not specific;
NS health limits ACGIH TLVs 2005 coal/silica |
|
Diesel vent'n |
4.6.1(3), 6.37.2 |
Pt.36.732 |
215,225(5) <1.25% |
100 |
Generically in all |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions |
|
Doors Closing |
6.38 |
Pt.36.714 |
213 (3) |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC requires auto
closing; Alta one door closed at any time |
|
Splits |
6.39 |
Pt.36.718/727/729 |
204 (2), 248 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, except CBDC |
|
Unventilated
Workings |
6.40.1 |
Pt.36.736(1) |
212, |
143-159 |
Generically in all |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions |
|
Stoppings/Seals/barricades? |
6.25, 6.40.2, 6.41 |
Pt.36.715/716/736 |
42, 207, 249, 212
barricades |
50, 155-157 |
Generically in all |
BC/NS/CBDC has no
time limit on setting seals; Alta < 3mths |
|
Explosion
Proof Stoppings |
6.40.2/6.41.1
(substantial) |
Pt.36.716 |
115(1) |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, except CBDC |
|
Methane
layering |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Pt 36 712(2) |
204(5) air
velo'y>20m/min |
126 |
Not in BC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, CBDC requiring detection and correction |
|
Methane
Drainage |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
250-252 |
50, |
Not in BC/Alta? |
Only in NS/CBDC
reflecting their higher methane contents |
|
Flammable Gas |
6.42 |
Pt.36.543/730-732 |
54, 234 |
110(2) intake;126-132 |
Generically in all |
Both BC and Alta
Codes require flammable gas monitors as |
|
Gas Detectors |
3.12/6.42.1/6.43.5 |
Pt.36.543/738-740[MSHA/UK/CSA] |
76, 120, 234 |
126, 132 |
Generically in all |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions |
|
Notify and
improve |
6.42.3 |
Pt.36.543.2 |
59, 125-128, 240 |
126 |
Generically in all |
BC @1.0%; Alta just
requires audible alarm @1.0% (20%LEL) |
|
No
blasting/diesels |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere (8.11.5(2)?) |
Pt.36.731.1.3/4; 732 |
225(1,c), 225(5), 393 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
BC/NS/CBDC not
specified; Alta @1.0% (20%LEL) |
|
Electricity
off |
6.42.4 |
Pt.36.731.1.2 |
234-240 |
130, |
Generically in all |
BC @1.25%; Alta
@1.25%(25%LEL); Ns non-gassy0.5%, gassy@1.25%; CBDC21.25% |
|
Withdraw
personnel |
6.42.5 |
Pt.36.731.1.1 |
27, 240, 243, |
130, |
Generically in all |
BC @ 2.50%; Alta @
2.50% (50%LEL); NS & CBDC@2.0% |
|
Prohibited
Metals ) |
6.36.3(4-5)/6.43.3 |
Pt.36.538 |
[160, 182(1,b)] 218
(1) |
CMSC |
Generically in all |
BC
bans Al, Mg, Ti or light metal alloy u/g; Alta bans lt.metal alloys+Al
blades; NS no mention of light alloys but bans on objects capable of
producing heat or fire; CBDC:CMSC req't |
|
Combustible
Dust |
2.3.5, 6.31, 6.44 |
Pt.36.742-744 |
180-186 |
133-136 |
Generically in all |
BC has more detail
than Alta; Alta has no limits<10m face; NS equiv to CBDC |
|
Dust on
floor, roof, sides |
6.44.1 |
Pt.36.743.3/4 |
182-186 |
133-136 |
Generically in all |
BC >30% H2O or <50% combustibles; Alta
>30%H2O or <35%
combustibles |
|
Volatile
Matter adjustment |
6.44.2 |
Pt.36.743.6 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in NS/CBDC? |
BC decr.of 1.5%
comb.s for each1.0% incr. In VM; Alta same for VM<32% |
|
Methane in
air adjustment |
6.44.4 |
Pt.36.743.5 |
184, |
134, |
Generically in all |
BC incr of 1% combs
per 0.1%CH4 if>0.25%CH4&Alta if VM>32%;
NS just %com;Fed1%25>20%. |
|
Explosion
Barriers |
6.45 |
Pt.36.745 |
181, |
137, |
Generically in all |
BCdry&dusty mines
to Mgr's scheme; Alta by PEng design <200m face; NS
generic;Fed<300mface. |
|
Sources of
Ignition |
6.43 |
Pt.36.693 |
45-46 |
138-141 |
Generically in all |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions |
|
Avoidance of
flammable mat's |
4.8 |
Pt.19.277 |
162, |
144-145 |
Generically in all |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
SHAFTS &
HOISTING |
7.1 to 7.9 |
Pt.6 |
38-9,44,93-95/97-102,272-3,290-365 |
63-81, 93-96 |
Generically in all |
BC/NS more detail
than Alta. |
|
Non-destructive
rope testing |
7.9.6 |
Pt.6.89 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
69, Sch I |
Not in NS? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, except NS |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
COMMUNICATIONS
& SIGNALS |
7.7/ 4.18.11 |
Pt.6.108/36.697-699 |
81/82/92 |
62, 96 |
Generically in all |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, except NS |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
RECORDS OF
FAILURES |
7.9.18 |
Pt.36.534 |
27 (2-4) |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in CBDC? |
Varying detail across
the jurisdictions, except CBDC |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EXPLOSIVES/BLASTING |
8.11.1-7 |
Pt.33;
Pt.36.607-642/658-679 |
Pt 11 (366-423) |
Pt I (10-34) Sch II |
Generically in all |
BC ref. Explosive Act
(Canada), NRCan Explosives Branch |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
CSA Standard M421-00,
"Storage Standards for Industrial Explosives". |
|
OTHER
STANDARDS (Separate List) |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Pt.1.3 |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not found, maybe
elsewhere |
Not in BC/NS/CBDC? |
Alta
Code refers to "National" Standards only in Part 33; NS specifies
NRCan Expl.Br, CSA M421-00 & certification of blasting m/c by
MSHA/CANMET. A common list for BC, NS & CBDC maybe useful |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|